A Narrative Literature Review on The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy
Main Article Content
Abstract
The field of psychotherapy is continuously evolving, with new therapeutic approaches being developed and existing ones refined to address a wide array of psychological issues. Therefore one systematic and comprehensive overview is needed. This narrative literature review systematically compiles and comprehensively overviews various psychotherapies, including psychoanalysis, cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), humanistic-existential therapy, art therapy, music therapy, story-drama therapy, and Rabindrik psychotherapy. Conducted through a comprehensive search of databases like Science Direct, APA Psyc Net, Pub Med, Google Scholar, and other sources, as well as relevant conferences, the review focused on English-language peer-reviewed articles published between 2014 and 2024. Excluding non-English articles and those published before 2014, data extraction involved a systematic review of study characteristics and outcomes, with thematic analysis synthesizing common patterns and findings across selected studies. Findings indicate psychoanalysis and psychodynamic psychotherapy sustain efficacy in treating mood and anxiety disorders, despite challenges such as small sample sizes and methodological constraints. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) shows broad efficacy, though questions persist regarding the long-term impact and technological barriers. Culturally specific modalities like Rabindra Sangeet and Rabindrik values enhance emotional self-awareness, yet generalizability remains limited. Further research on existential, humanistic, art, drama, and music therapies is crucial to refine applications and validate efficacy across diverse clinical settings. The review underscores varied therapeutic efficacy across contexts, with promising results from psychoanalysis and CBT but ongoing challenges in maintaining long-term effectiveness and methodological rigor. Culturally specific therapies and modalities like group art, drama, narrative, and music therapy demonstrate beneficial outcomes, necessitating standardized methodologies and larger-scale investigations to validate effectiveness across clinical settings. The project is funded by Rabindrik Psychotherapy Research Institute Trust, Kolkata
Article Details
References
Abbing, A., Baars, E. W., de Sonneville, L., Ponstein, A. S., & Swaab, H. (2019, May 29). The Effectiveness of Art Therapy for Anxiety in Adult Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Frontiers in Psychology, 10. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01203
Aguilera, A., Arévalo Avalos, M. R., Rosales, K., Reyes, Y., Hernandez-Ramos, R., Ramos, G., Garcia, E., Hoang, T., Ochoa-Frongia, L., Fortuna, L. R., & Schueller, S. M. (2024, February). Effectiveness-implementation hybrid trial of the Spanish language, digital cognitive-behavioral therapy (dCBT) intervention for depression and anxiety – protocol for the SUPERA (Support from PEeRs to expand Access) study. Contemporary Clinical Trials, 137, 107422. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cct.2023.107422
Bakhtarikia, S., Tavanai, E., Rouhbakhsh, N., Sayadi, A. J., & Sabet, V. K. (2024, July). Investigating the effectiveness of music therapy combined with binaural beats on chronic tinnitus: A randomized controlled trial. American Journal of Otolaryngology, 45(4), 104308. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amjoto.2024.104308
Basu, S. (2019). Emotional self-awareness through Rabindra Sangeet. Rabindrik Psychotherapy Research Institute. Paper presented at the conference held at Jadavpur University. https://rpriedu.blogspot.com/2019/04/
Basu, T. (2019, April 21). Test-retest reliability of flow experience in Rabindra Sangeet. Rabindrik Psychotherapy Research Institute. Paper presented at the conference held at Jadavpur University.https://rpriedu.blogspot.com/2019/04/
Beaudoin, M. N., Moersch, M., & Evare, B. S. (2016). The effectiveness of narrative therapy with children’s social and emotional skill development: An empirical study of 813 problem-solving stories. Journal of Systemic Therapies, 35(3), 42–59. https://doi.org/10.1521/jsyt.2016.35.3.42
Briggs, S., Netuveli, G., Gould, N., et al. (2019). The effectiveness of psychoanalytic/psychodynamic psychotherapy for reducing suicide attempts and self-harm: Systematic review and meta-analysis. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 214(6), 320-328. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.2019.33
Chan, S. H., Cheung, M. Y., Chiu, A. T., Leung, M. H., Kuo, M. C., Yip, D. Y., Hui, C. C., Kam, S. W., Yeung, K., Mui, D. S., Wang, S. M., & Yip, C. C. (2023, December). Clinical effectiveness of mindfulness-based music therapy on improving emotional regulation in blind older women: A randomized controlled trial. Integrative Medicine Research, 12(4), 100993. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.imr.2023.100993
Daei Jafari, M. R., Aghaei, A., & Rashidi Rad, M. (2020). Existential humanistic therapy with couples and its effect on the meaning of life and love attitudes. The American Journal of Family Therapy, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/01926187.2020.1770142
Daengruan, P., Chairat, R., Jenraumjit, R., Chinwong, D., Oon-arom, A., Klaphajone, J., & Arunmanakul, P. (2021, September). Effectiveness of receptive music therapy with embedded 10 Hz binaural beats compared with standard care for patients with major depressive disorder: A randomized controlled trial. Complementary Therapies in Medicine, 61, 102765. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctim.2021.102765
Datta, M., & Dutta Roy, D. (n.d.). A case study on Rabindrik value preferences on HIV (human immunodeficiency virus) positive patients. Paper presentation on conferences held at Jadavpur University, Rabindra Psychotherapy Research Institute. https://rpriedu.blogspot.com/2019/04/
.Dey, S., & Dutta Roy, D. (2019). Flow diagram analysis of high and low anxious persons in listening to Rabindra Sangeet. Indian Institute of Psychometry, Kolkata, & Psychology Research Unit, Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata. https://rpriedu.blogspot.com/2019/04/
De Gruijter, E., Wouters, H., & Haeyen, S. (2024). Perceived effects of drama therapy in people diagnosed with personality disorders: A qualitative study. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 87,102117. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2024.102117
Doomen, L. (2018). The effectiveness of schema-focused drama therapy for cluster C personality disorders: An exploratory study. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 61,66-76. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2017.12.002
Feizi, M., Kamali, Z., Gholami, M., Abadi, G. A. H., & Moeini, S. (2019). The effectiveness of existential psychotherapy on attitude to life and self-flourishing of educated women homemakers. Journal of Education and Health Promotion, 8(1), 237. https://doi.org/10.4103/jehp.jehp_473_18
Gonzalez, A., Xavier, T., Amarante, N., Barros, R., Amaral, B., Bernardino, M., & Lima, M. (2022). Playback theatre: Group, stories, and stage as elements of change. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 81, 101968. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2022.10196
.Griffin, C., Fenner, P., Landorf, K. B., & Cotchett, M. (2021, November). Effectiveness of art therapy for people with eating disorders: A mixed methods systematic review. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 76, 101859. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2021.101859
Huang, C., & Gu, S. (2024, March). Effectiveness of music therapy in enhancing empathy and emotional recognition in adolescents with intellectual disabilities. Acta Psychologica, 243, 104152. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104152
Jalambadani, Z., & Borji, A. (2019, April). Effectiveness of Mindfulness-Based Art Therapy on Healthy Quality of Life in Women with Breast Cancer. Asia-Pacific Journal of Oncology Nursing, 6(2), 193–197. https://doi.org/10.4103/apjon.apjon_36_18
Knekt, P., Heinonen, E., & Lindfors, O. (2018). Follow-up of the effectiveness of long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy and psychoanalysis 5 years after the end of psychoanalysis: Minor differences in psychiatric symptoms and workability. Neurology, Psychiatry, and Brain Research, 30, 163-166. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.2019.33
Lee, J. H. (2021, April). Effectiveness of group art therapy for mothers of children with disabilities. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 73, 101754. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2020.101754
.Lindfors, O., Knekt, P., Lehtonen, J., Virtala, E., Maljanen, T., & Härkänen, T. (2019). Effectiveness of psychoanalysis and long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy on personality and social functioning 10 years after the start of treatment. Psychiatry Research, 272, 774-783. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychres.2018.12.082
Lybbert, R., Ryland, S., & Bean, R. (2019). Existential interventions for adolescent suicidality: Practical interventions to target the root causes of adolescent distress. Children and Youth Services Review, 100, 98-104. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2019.02.028
Matsumoto, K., Hamatani, S., & Shimizu, E. (2024). Long-term effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of guided internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy for obsessive-compulsive disorder: 24-month follow-up. Internet Interventions, 35.
Mirzajani, H., Nekoi, F., & Nekoi, H. (2023). The effectiveness of story therapy on emotion regulation and anxiety symptoms in children with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Pouyesh in Education and Consultation (JPEC), 1402(18), 133-149.
Panigrahi, S., & Dutta Roy, D. (2019.). Single subject case study on psychological stress management through Rabindrik psychotherapy. Rabindrik Psychotherapy Research Institute.Paper presented at the conference held at Jadavpur University. https://rpriedu.blogspot.com/2019/04/
Pearce, P., Sewell, R., Cooper, M., Osman, S., Fugard, A. J. B., & Pybis, J. (2016). Effectiveness of school-based humanistic counseling for psychological distress in young people: Pilot randomized controlled trial with follow-up in an ethnically diverse sample. Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 90(2), 138–155. https://doi.org/10.1111/papt.12102
Raglio, A., Imbriani, M., Imbriani, C., Baiardi, P., Manzoni, S., Gianotti, M., Castelli, M., Vanneschi, L., Vico, F., & Manzoni, L. (2020, March). Machine learning techniques to predict the effectiveness of music therapy: A randomized controlled trial. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 185, 105160. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmpb.2019.105160
Rezazadeh Yazd, S. A., Gashtil, S., Moradpoor, M., Pishdar, S., Nabian, P., Kazemi, Z., & Naeim, M. (2023, July). Reducing depression and anxiety symptoms in patients with Parkinson’s disease: The effectiveness of group cognitive behavioral therapy. Parkinsonism & Related Disorders, 112, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.parkreldis.2023.105456
Rodriguez-Muñoz, M., Radoš, S. N., Uka, A., Marques, M., Maia, B., Matos, M., Branquinho, M., Aydın, R., Mahmoodi, V., Chrzan-Dętkoś, M., Walczak-Kozłowska, T., & Liakea, I. (2023, December). Effectiveness of the third wave cognitive behavior therapy for peripartum depression treatment–A systematic review. Midwifery, 127, 103865. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.midw.2023.103865
Rosli, M. R., Rafae, N. M., & Alim, A. A. A. (2022). The effectiveness of existential therapy in reducing the level of depression among residents in moral rehabilitation schools. Journal Contemporary of Islamic Counselling Perspective, 1(1).
Sadhu, M., & Sarangi, A. (2024). Life story books as a reminiscence therapy tool for dementia: An updated review from 2018-2023. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 32(4), S42. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jagp.2024.01.113
Schimmers, N., Breeksema, J., Smith, Y., Veraart, J. A., Brink, W., & Schoevers, R. (2022). Psychedelics for the treatment of depression, anxiety, and existential distress in patients with a terminal illness: A systematic review. Psychopharmacology, 239, 15-33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00213-021-06027-y
Şenol, F. B., & Şenol, Y. (2024). The effect of drama on psychosocial problems and emotional states of hospitalized children with cancer. Journal of Pediatric Nursing. https://doi.org/10styleType
Shah, H., & Dutta Roy, D. (2014). Structure of Rabindrik human values. Indian Journal of Positive Psychology, 5(4), 368-375.
Sharkiya, S. H. (2024, March). The effectiveness of music therapy in reducing perioperative pain and anxiety: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Perioperative Care and Operating Room Management, 34, 100360. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pcorm.2023.100360
Sharp, P., Davi, K., Rice, S., Seidler, Z., Oliffe, J., & John, S. (2022). Existential isolation and psychological distress during COVID-19: The role of loneliness and resilient coping in Canadian help-seeking men. Journal of Affective Disorders, 324, 279-285. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2022.12.133
Shepherd, C., & Beail, N. (2017). A systematic review of the effectiveness of psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic and psychodynamic psychotherapy with adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities: Progress and challenges. Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, 31(1), 94-117. https://doi.org/10.1080/02668734.2017.1286610
Sweetman, A., Lovato, N., Micic, G., Scott, H., Bickley, K., Haycock, J., Harris, J., Gradisar, M., & Lack, L. (2020, November). Do symptoms of depression, anxiety, or stress impair the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia
Shayganfard, M., Kaboudi, B., Arabsheibani, K., Shakiba, E., & Cheshmekaboudi, S. (2024). Effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral group play therapy on anxiety-based school refusal and behavioral problems in elementary school boys: A preliminary randomized controlled trial. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 50, 108-114.
Vezmar, M., Ćirović, N., Sudar, B., Buzejić, J., Jovanović, T., Radanović, A., & Vezmar, M. (2024, July). The effectiveness of group art therapy in a clinically heterogenous sample: Randomized controlled trial. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 89, 102150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2024.102150
Vos, J., Craig, M., & Cooper, M. (2015). Existential therapies: A meta-analysis of their effects on psychological outcomes. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 83(1), 115-128. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0037167
Wang, C., Si, H., Bian, Y., Qiao, X., Ji, L., Liu, Q., Wang, W., Yu, J., Li, Y., Zhou, W., Yue, W., Liu, J., & Jin, Y. (2024, February). Effectiveness of subjective support-focused cognitive behavioral therapy on depressive symptoms among (pre)frail community-dwelling older adults: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Affective Disorders, 347, 92–100. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2023.11.058
Weitkamp, K., Daniels, J. K., Hofmann, H., Timmermann, H., Romer, G., & Wiegand-Grefe, S. (2014). Psychoanalytic psychotherapy for children and adolescents with severe depressive psychopathology: Preliminary results of an effectiveness trial. Psychotherapy, 51(1), 138-147. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0034178
Wu, J., Chen, K., Ma, Y., & Vomočilová, J. (2020). Early intervention for children with intellectual and developmental disability using drama therapy techniques. Children and Youth Services Review, 109,104689. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2019.104689
Yang, W. J., Bai, Y. M., Qin, L., Xu, X. L., Bao, K. F., Xiao, J. L., & Ding, G. W. (2019, November). The effectiveness of music therapy for postpartum depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice, 37, 93–101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2019.09.002
Zhong, K., An, X., & Kong, Y. (2024, March). The effectiveness of five-element music therapy for post-stroke depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Heliyon, 10(5), e26603. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e26603